Are Your Beliefs Really Your Own?
From Inherited Beliefs to Mature Faith – Chapter Six in The Seven Stones
Have you ever stopped to consider how many of the things you believe are actually your own beliefs?
Not the things you've been taught. Not the things your parents believed. Not the things your church, community, or society told you were true.
But the things you have personally examined, questioned, wrestled with, and ultimately come to believe for yourself.
It's an interesting question, isn't it?
From the moment we're born, we begin absorbing the beliefs of the people around us. Our parents teach us what's right and wrong, what's important, what success looks like, and what we should believe about God.
And because we love and trust them, we accept much of what they tell us without question.
That's not necessarily a bad thing. Children need guidance, structure, and a foundation upon which to build their understanding of the world.
But eventually, we grow up.
Or at least we're supposed to.
When Inherited Beliefs Become Our Own
I grew up in a deeply Christian household. Faith was an important part of our family, and from an early age, I was taught what to believe about God, heaven, hell, and the consequences of rejecting those beliefs.
My mother once warned me that if I didn't believe in God, I would go to hell.
She was sharing what she sincerely believed, and I have no doubt her intentions were pure.
But there's a difference between believing something because someone you trust tells you it's true and believing something because you've come to understand and embrace it yourself.
For much of my early life, I understood the teachings of Christianity without developing a meaningful personal relationship with Christ.
I knew what I was supposed to believe.
But did I really believe it?
And perhaps more importantly, did those beliefs actually influence the way I lived?
What Psychology Teaches Us About Faith
Developmental psychologist and theologian James Fowler spent much of his career studying how faith develops throughout our lives.
He recognized that many people initially adopt the beliefs of their families and communities. As we mature, however, we may begin questioning those assumptions and developing a more personally examined faith.
Harvard psychologist Robert Kegan approached human development from a different perspective but arrived at a related insight.
Kegan described the movement from what he called the Socialized Mind, in which our identity and beliefs are heavily influenced by the expectations of others, toward the Self-Authoring Mind, in which we develop the capacity to examine those expectations and determine what we genuinely believe.
Neither psychologist was suggesting that we must reject everything we've been taught.
Rather, their work helps explain an important distinction:
There is a difference between inheriting a belief and taking personal ownership of it.
Sometimes Life Forces Us to Reconsider
In my own life, that transformation didn't occur in a classroom or through an intellectual exercise.
It came through suffering.
For years, I struggled with alcoholism. I pleaded with a God I wasn't even certain existed to remove the addiction that was destroying my life.
But I eventually came to recognize something about myself.
I wanted God to remove the consequences of my alcoholism while I continued controlling virtually everything else.
I wanted relief without surrender.
It was through adversity, humility, and finally relinquishing my stubborn insistence on controlling my own life that the faith I had inherited began becoming the faith I personally embraced.
I didn't simply come to believe that God existed because my parents had told me so.
I came to believe because I experienced His presence and transforming power in my own life.
The beliefs hadn't necessarily changed.
But the person holding those beliefs had.
Mature Faith Doesn't Mean Having Every Answer
I think we sometimes confuse mature faith with absolute certainty.
We imagine that spiritual maturity means reaching a point where we no longer question, doubt, or struggle.
But perhaps the opposite is true.
Perhaps mature faith involves having the courage to confront difficult questions, acknowledge what we don't understand, and continue seeking truth.
Faith that has never been examined may be comfortable.
But comfort and conviction are not necessarily the same thing.
In my forthcoming book, The Seven Stones, I explore seven transformations that I believe help us become the people we were created to be.
The fifth is From Inherited Beliefs to Mature Faith.
Its central question is simple:
What do I truly believe?
Not what have I been told to believe.
Not what would make my parents proud.
Not what will earn the approval of my friends, my church, or my community.
What do I genuinely believe, and why?
Because eventually, our beliefs must become more than ideas we've inherited.
They must become convictions that shape the way we live.
And perhaps that's where mature faith really begins.